Men VS Women
In general, it’s usually always the man who gets caught cheating in a relationship whether married or not. In this story it’s just the opposite; a woman who enters into a secret and passionate endeavor simply out of retaliating from being wrongfully accused by a man’s wife. This is revealed When Osen depressingly states, “My sleeve is already wet with tears. Having suffered the shame, there is nothing left to lose. I shall make love to Chozaemon and teach that woman a lesson” (Saikaku 602). This statement depicts a spiteful woman who is being governed by her emotions in addition to being led by bitter thoughts and lack of sound reasoning.
Driven by her passion for Chozaemon, Osen makes the mistake of allowing him to follow her home. Most men would immediately have turned the woman around from following him home to his wife and make allowances to meet her some time later. Osen, being a woman and probably thinking with her passion filled brain, not only allowed him to follow her home, but she foolishly let him into her home to fulfill their raging desires. This turned out to be a tragedy brought on by “a woman’s scorn”. Had the shoe been on the other foot and if the man was found in Osen’s place, I wonder if he would have taken his own life. I think not because most men don’t have the valor to take their own lives especially when it involves cheating with a woman or another man: it’s just a man thing. This is also revealed in the sentence that states, “Naked and terrified, he dashed out and ran a great distance to the house of a close relative …” (Saikaku 603). Here again is a true picture of a man at his best, running away and giving no thought as to what happens to the woman. Executing and reuniting him with Osen after he is finally caught. Here is just the thing that the Enlightenment Period was against, being ruled by passion and emotional impulses instead of sound judgment and good reasoning.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteComment #1
ReplyDeleteGreat entry Renee. I agree with you whole heartly. Women scorned can get in alot of trouble and Osen let her passion over rule all that she taught she held dear which is shown in the statements "Osen took especially good care of the Cooper...[E]ven when, after several years and months, she bore two children, Osen did not forsake her husband for them. She gave all she thought she treasured away to be scornful and ended up getting caught up in the passion of the situation."(Saikaku 600) I taught it sad though that it all happened behind a unfortunite situation being blown out of proportion.
------------------------------------------------
I deleted this comment to try and fix my errors.
--------------------------------
I agree with this post 100%. When I first started reading the story, Osen was thought highly of, an kind of respected by some of the people around her. Then all because of being accused of sleeping with a man, whom she didn't sleep wit at first, caused her to go on an sleep with him.. Yea, she had already been embarrased, and looked down upon, so she thought, I might as well, they already accusing me. She was doing this, trying to get revenge on the woman, and ended up taking her own life. In the middle of her " rendevous" she was caught by her husband. This was all to much for her to bare, an she felt like taking her own life would be the solution.
ReplyDeleteI totally agree! The ending of this story took me by surprise and I enjoyed it very much. During the whole fiasco of everyone that fornicated being killed - nobody spoke of Chozaemon's jealous wife again. She was accusing Osen of cheating..."What a playful bowl that must be. If you ask me, somebody fell into bed without going to sleep and her hair came undone" (Saikaku 602). The lady of the house kept on and kept on until Osen had had enough and thought that she would show her! Osen did not win in the end, but neither did the jealous wife! Osen lost her life, but the jealous wife lost her husband and found out that he was cheating. At least the man in this story (Chozaemon) got what he deserved - a good, old-fashioned execution and being laid to rest in the Shame Field!
ReplyDelete(146 words)
Renee, I totally agree with you. No man would take his life out of shame, for being caught having an affiar. Instead he would probably be boastful and walk around like a peacock with his feathers out.I like how you said he just ran away, That too is typical of most men.
ReplyDelete